Colossian Blog
January 28, 2013 | Daniel Camacho

Politics in the Church?

Politics can get nasty. Just recall the Facebook comments, “debates,” and “purges” that accompanied our nation’s last presidential election. Discussing politics with others—whether it’s on the topic of gay marriage, gun control, or taxes—does not seem to be worth the price for all of the incendiary reactions that ensue. The results appear to be even worse when we try to bring politics into the church. As Christians, we can mimic the polarization in our society and end up with pews that are painted red and blue.

In responding to the dangers of partisan politics, the temptation then becomes to assume that the gospel is apolitical. The church should focus more on worship and personal evangelism rather than politics. However, upon further reflection, this turns out to be a contradiction in terms. Our worship is and always has been political.

What does it mean that our worship is political? For some, this might sound odd. Confusion arises over what is meant by ‘political’ because it can be understood in different ways. In our commonplace usage of the word today, ‘politics’ refers to government, policy, or even pursuing one’s own interests in other contexts (e.g. ‘church politics’). But there is another, older, sense to this term. Our word ‘politics’ finds its roots in the Greek words politika (affairs of the city) and politikos (relating to citizens). In this sense, politics includes things such as policy but also encompasses much more. Politics are about how a community is ordered. In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle subsumes his inquiry about ethics and human flourishing under political science. The good of the individual is inextricably bound to the good of the polis, the city or state, and its ordering.

It is in this latter, and broader, sense that worship is political. Worship initiates and trains us into the Christian community. Beyond the state, the notion of polis as a moral community can also be applied to the church. Scripture describes the church as a “holy nation” (1 Pet. 2:9) and our participation in that community as a “heavenly citizenship” (Phil. 3:20). In following Christ, we become oriented towards a new community that requires our primary allegiance: the church, the city of God, the Body of Christ. Rodney Clapp, in A Peculiar People: The Church as Culture in a Post-Christian Society, shows how it is no coincidence that the New Testament—in continuity with the Old Testament—uses many words (e.g. kingdom, gospel, liturgy, church) that were politically charged for its time. Clapp writes:

[div id=”blockquote”]Perhaps the main reason the Bible has, at least in recent centuries, seemed to offer scarce political or cultural guidance is that Christians have read a “rank anachronism” back into its text. The strict split between “religion” and “politics” belongs to centuries much later than the first. As N.T. Wright remarks, “No first-century Jew…could imagine that the worship of their god and the organization of human society were matters related only at a tangent.”[1][end-div]

As Clapp and Wright have argued, the split between religion and politics, and the distinction between public and private, do not adequately explain the nature of Christian worship. There was a good reason why the early Christians were persecuted when they recognized Jesus, and not Caesar, as Lord. To split our faith from our politics is dangerous because it blinds us from seeing competing allegiances. In the context of Apartheid South Africa, loyalty to the government’s policies entailed a contradiction of Christian baptism, a denial of the church’s catholicity, and a distorted view of the Imago Dei.

Separating our worship from our politics neglects the way in which our worship is a form of politics, and the way in which it can inform our involvement in our government’s politics. From this vantage point, a Christian is always involved in two kinds of politics. To borrow from Augustine’s The City of God, Christians are simultaneously involved in the politics of the heavenly polis and the politics of the earthly polis. Our participation in the Body of Christ gives shape to our involvement in society at large.

Tithing and providing resources to the needy—to think of one type of example—are practices in the church that reflect how our worship is political. Living and acting out of a deep trust in God’s provision ought to shape all of our economic practices. Therefore, the way in which we handle resources, or money, speaks about the kingdom we are members of—a kingdom that does not operate out of a fear of scarcity (Matt. 6:25-34). Understanding this ought to help us imagine and negotiate the economic realities in broader society.  To separate the economics implied in our worship from the economic policies of markets and governments is to short-circuit the implications of our discipleship to Christ.

Here at TCF, we are not into partisan politics, but rather when we discuss politics we understand the political in a broader sense that affirms the public nature and implications of worship. As our Manifesto states: “Worship trains us in our rights and duties as citizens of the City of God.” When it comes to politics understood in the more narrow sense (i.e. in the earthly city), and to specific policies, we realize that Christians can often disagree. Nevertheless, we want to affirm that our shared practices of Christian worship constitute a “civics class” for us as a church, a training that can help us navigate through the ‘nasty’ politics, together, with charity.

[1] Clapp, Rodney. A Peculiar People: The Church as Culture in a Post-Christian Society. InterVarsity Press, 1996.

Suggested Posts
Formed Through the Crucible of Conflict
October 12, 2016 | Michael Gulker
Formed Through the Crucible of Conflict
Our president, Michael Gulker, wrote an article for the recent CSE (Christian School Education) magazine about finding our way through conflict when teaching about faith and science. Enjoy! We had gathered in hopes of using tough, complex conversations like evolution as occasions to deepen faith and witness to the truth that all things hold together in Christ (Colossians 1:17). But things sure didn't feel like they were holding together as we factionalized into two groups--those insisting on the authority of Scripture and those insisting on the need to take science seriously and teach it with integrity. Things had started so well. We began the two-day retreat in prayer and worship, meditating on Mary's annunciation in Luke 1, reflecting on what it might mean for Christ to be born in us in the midst of a pressured conversation like evolution. Later, we read Psalm 22, the opening line of which Jesus quoted from the cross--"My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" How are we to act when we, who have been given authority for both the intellectual and spiritual formation of our students, come face-to-face with challenging conversations that threaten to call our own faith into question? How are we to balance our teaching authority and our confidence in Scripture with openness and vulnerability to new learning? And what, in our culture, did students need to see most--a tidy answer or a faithful question to a God whom we can trust to see things through even we we can't? You can read the rest of the article from CSE here.
Certainty Isn't the Point
October 4, 2016 | Michael Gulker
Certainty Isn't the Point
Dear Friends, As you may recall, we’ve recently finished our first pilot of The Colossian Way. Since that time, we’ve been diligently compiling feedback from leaders, participants, and expert reviewers. We’re keen to make certain that what we share with our partners in this next revision be a deep and rich experience for Christian communities seeking to hold truth and love together in the midst of conflict. Thankfully, even in our striving, we have friends like you who remind us that true faithfulness lies beyond our attempts to achieve certainty in our work. Recently Rob Barrett, the primary author of The Colossian Way participant guide, stepped away from the piles of feedback and revision planning to spend an evening with one of our pilot group leaders. As they sat together on her front porch enjoying the sounds and smells of summer, Rob saw first-hand how deeply committed she was to her community as neighbors stopped in throughout the evening to share bits of their lives including their fears and hopes. Interspersed throughout these visits, this leader reflected on how she and her group experienced The Colossian Way—their ups and downs, their joys and sorrows, their delights and frustrations with the process itself. The future of this leader’s church community is uncertain and she was clear that The Colossian Way didn’t change that. Yet, she continues to pray for us and is eager to see how she can be involved in the next steps of The Colossian Way experience. Faithfulness to her community isn’t measured by certainty, but by friendship amidst uncertainty. How deeply grateful we are for her friendship and this timely reminder. We can so quickly forget that certainty isn’t the point as we follow Jesus in this polarized culture. Yes, we want to work hard to hone The Colossian Way, but even this effort won’t guarantee its success. Thankfully, our success has already been accomplished in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. Now the Lord is inviting us to participate in his certain success by laying down our lives for our brothers and sisters while they (and we) are yet sinners, even when the shape of our future together is uncertain. What does that look like? For starters, each day we have the choice of putting tasks first or laying down our lives (starting with our precious productivity time) for those whom Christ has given us. I’m the first to admit that it’s tough to break free of the to-do list to offer significant time to folks who don’t move my personal or professional projects toward certain success (pray for me!). But if we take seriously The Great Commandment, it’s clear that success, in its deepest and most certain sense, means: (1) loving God and (2) loving our neighbor. I encourage you to be open to the Spirit’s prompting to lay down just a little bit of your life this month (yes, in the midst of the new routines and rhythms of autumn) for that person of whom you are just a little uncertain. This post is excerpted from our October prayer letter. To receive the prayer letter in your inbox, click on the button below. Subscribe! To the monthly prayer letter.